Pusheen Surprise Plush: What's Inside and How to Collect

Quick answer

Each Pusheen surprise plush capsule contains one squishy figurine, and the available designs are listed on the product page. Ordering five capsules does not guarantee you will receive all five designs, so treat every capsule as a single random pull. Buy from a retailer that states the full design lineup, keep capsules sealed until you decide whether to trade, and pick a series you actually like rather than chasing a complete set.

Pusheen surprise plush is a blind-box format: you know the series and the possible designs, but not which one is inside your capsule. That uncertainty is the fun part, and it is also the part that trips up new collectors who assume a five-pack will complete the set.

This guide walks through a practical collecting process, from reading the product page before checkout to storing dupes and trading with other fans. It uses the Gamer Pusheen Surprise Squishy and Pusheen Boba Tea Surprise Squishy as working examples because both list five designs and both come with the same no-returns rule on opened packages.

What is actually inside a Pusheen surprise plush capsule

A Pusheen surprise plush capsule holds exactly one squishy figurine. The Gamer Pusheen Surprise Squishy is a bouncy, water-filled squishy made of soft, mochi-like material, and the series includes five gamer-themed designs. The Pusheen Boba Tea Surprise Squishy is soft and stretchy, filled with boba pearls, and comes in an eco-friendly cardboard capsule with five designs: Pusheen, Stormy, Pip, Sloth, and Bo.

Both products are sold as single capsules, not as a guaranteed set. The catalog notes that ordering five does not guarantee you will receive all five designs. That wording matters because it tells you the capsules are packed randomly rather than sorted into one-of-each bundles.

• Check the product page for the full design list before buying, so you know what you are hoping to pull.
• Do not assume a five-capsule order equals a complete set.

Why the no-returns rule changes how you buy

Opened surprise capsules cannot be returned or exchanged. That policy is standard for blind-box collectibles because once the seal is broken, the item can no longer be sold as new. It also means your buying decision happens before you see the figure, not after.

Plan around that by deciding your budget per series up front. If you only want one or two designs, buy a small number of capsules and accept that you may not pull them. If you want the whole series, expect to buy more than five capsules or trade for the ones you miss.

• Set a capsule budget before you order, since opened packages are final sale.
• Keep capsules sealed until you have decided whether to open or trade them.

How to collect a full Pusheen mystery plush series

Start by writing down the design list from the product page. For the boba tea series that means Pusheen, Stormy, Pip, Sloth, and Bo; for the gamer series it means the five gamer designs shown in the listing. Track which ones you pull so you stop buying duplicates blindly.

Then decide whether you are collecting to complete or collecting to enjoy. Completion usually requires trading, because random packing can hand you the same design repeatedly. Enjoyment collecting is simpler: buy a few capsules, keep the ones you like, and pass the rest along.

• Keep a simple checklist of pulled designs so you know what you still need.
• Trade dupes with other collectors rather than buying more capsules hoping for a specific figure.

Storing and displaying your pulls

Squishy figures are soft and can pick up dust or lint, so give them a dedicated spot rather than tossing them loose in a drawer. A small shelf, a clear display box, or a labeled bag per series keeps them identifiable and makes trading easier later.

Keep the cardboard capsule if you plan to trade or resell, since the packaging helps confirm which series a figure came from. If you are displaying them, rotate figures occasionally so the same squishy is not always pressed against a surface.

• Store each series separately so you can find a specific design quickly.
• Keep capsules for figures you might trade.

Your step-by-step surprise plush collecting process

1. Step 1: Read the design list before checkout: Open the product page and note how many designs are in the series and whether they are named. The Boba Tea series names Pusheen, Stormy, Pip, Sloth, and Bo; the Gamer series lists five gamer designs. If the listing does not name the designs, treat that as a limitation and decide whether the mystery is still worth it to you. Checkpoint: you should be able to write down every possible design before you pay.
2. Step 2: Set a capsule budget and stick to it: Because opened packages cannot be returned or exchanged, every capsule is a final purchase. Decide how many you are willing to open before you order, and treat that number as the cap rather than adding one more capsule each time you miss a design. Checkpoint: your budget should be based on enjoyment, not on the assumption that the next capsule completes the set.
3. Step 3: Open one capsule at a time and log the pull: Open a single capsule, note which design you got, and add it to a checklist. This stops you from losing track of dupes and makes it obvious when you already own a design you just pulled again. Checkpoint: if you pull a duplicate, move it to a trade pile instead of opening another capsule immediately.
4. Step 4: Trade or gift duplicates instead of overbuying: Since ordering five capsules does not guarantee all five designs, duplicates are normal. Swap them with other collectors or gift them, and only buy more capsules if you genuinely want another random pull rather than a specific figure. Checkpoint: a full set usually comes from trading, not from buying more capsules.
5. Step 5: Store and display your collection: Keep each series in its own labeled bag or shelf space, and hold onto the cardboard capsule for figures you may trade. Soft squishy material collects dust, so a covered or closed display spot keeps figures looking clean. Next step: once your checklist is mostly complete, decide whether to display the set together or keep trading toward the last few designs.

Product facts that affect collecting

• Gamer Pusheen Surprise Squishy: Each capsule contains 1 squishy figurine, and the series includes five gamer designs. The squishy is bouncy, water-filled, and made of soft, mochi-like material. Ordering 5 does not guarantee you will receive all 5 designs, and opened packages cannot be returned or exchanged. Buy this series if you enjoy gamer-themed designs and are comfortable with random pulls. Do not buy five capsules expecting a guaranteed full set, and do not open one you might want to return.
• Pusheen Boba Tea Surprise Squishy: Each capsule contains 1 squishy figurine from five boba tea designs: Pusheen, Stormy, Pip, Sloth, and Bo. The squishy is soft and stretchy with boba pearl filling and comes in an eco-friendly cardboard capsule. Ordering 5 does not guarantee all 5 designs, and opened packages cannot be returned or exchanged. This is the better pick if you want a named character list to collect toward, since the five designs are spelled out. The cardboard capsule is also easier to keep for trading than a plastic shell.

Pusheen surprise plush is best enjoyed as a random pull, not a guaranteed set. Read the design list, budget for the capsules you actually want to open, log your pulls, and trade duplicates. That approach keeps the surprise fun and the spending predictable.