Pusheen Piggy Bank vs Magnetic Keychain Holder: Which to Buy?
By Pusheen Shop | Published: 2026-10-13
Category: Comparisons
Compare the Pusheen Piggy Bank and Pusheen Magnetic Keychain Holder on purpose, mounting, and coin access so you can pick the right desk or entryway organizer.
Quick Answer
Choose the Pusheen Piggy Bank if you want a freestanding savings spot with a twist-off cap for retrieving coins and bills. Choose the Pusheen Magnetic Keychain Holder if your priority is keeping three keychains off the floor with dedicated magnetic slots and included mounting hardware. They solve different problems, so the right pick depends on whether you are saving money or organizing keys.
What Each Pusheen Desk Accessory Is Actually For
The Pusheen Piggy Bank is a vinyl coin holder with a slot at the top for deposits and a screw cap at the bottom that twists off to remove coins and bills. That design makes it a one-way container during everyday use and a quick-access bank when you need cash. It sits on a surface, so it works on a desk, shelf, or dresser without any installation.
The Pusheen Magnetic Keychain Holder is a wall-mounted key rack that includes three keychains: Pusheen, Stormy, and Pip. Each key ring fits into its own dedicated magnetic slot to prevent slipping or falling, and the set ships with two wall plugs and two screws for mounting. It is an entryway or door-side organizer rather than a savings tool.
Mounting and Placement Trade-Offs
The keychain holder requires a small commitment: you need to drill or drive two screws into a wall or door and use the supplied plugs. In exchange, you get keys that stay visible and reachable at the exact spot you leave the house. If you rent or do not want to put holes in a wall, that installation step is a real drawback.
The piggy bank asks for nothing but a flat surface. You can move it from desk to shelf whenever you rearrange, and there is no hardware to lose. The trade-off is that it takes up footprint space and does not hold keys, so it will not solve an entryway clutter problem.
Capacity and Daily Use
The piggy bank is built for accumulation. Coins go in through the top slot, and the bottom screw cap means you do not have to break anything to get them out. That makes it practical for loose change, folded bills, or a small savings goal. It is not designed to hold keys, cards, or anything larger than what fits through the slot.
The keychain holder is built for retrieval, not storage. Three magnetic slots hold the included Pusheen, Stormy, and Pip keychains, and each ring is meant to be grabbed and returned daily. It will not hold loose change or bills, so it is a poor fit if you want a single catch-all for pocket contents.
Trade-Offs to Weigh Before You Choose
- Wall commitment vs. surface freedom: The keychain holder needs two screws and wall plugs, so it stays put once mounted. The piggy bank needs no installation but occupies desk or shelf space. Pick the holder if you have a dedicated wall spot; pick the bank if you want zero holes and flexible placement.
- Key retrieval vs. coin retrieval: The holder's magnetic slots are designed for grabbing and returning three keychains daily. The bank's top slot accepts coins and its bottom screw cap opens for coins and bills. Match the access pattern to your routine: keys leave and return constantly, while savings go in and stay in.
- Included set vs. single-purpose item: The holder arrives with three character keychains and mounting hardware. The piggy bank is one vinyl coin holder with no accessories. If you want an out-of-the-box entryway setup, the holder covers more ground; if you want one focused savings object, the bank is simpler.
Product Facts at a Glance
- Pusheen Magnetic Keychain Holder: Includes three keychains of Pusheen, Stormy, and Pip, with each key ring fitting into dedicated magnetic slots to prevent slipping or falling. Two wall plugs and two screws are included for mounting. You get a complete three-key setup and the hardware needed to install it, so there is no extra trip for mounting supplies.
- Pusheen Piggy Bank: Vinyl coin holder with a slot at the top to deposit coins and a screw cap at the bottom that twists off to remove coins and bills. You can add money without opening it and retrieve it later without damaging the bank, which suits ongoing saving rather than one-time storage.
Which Pusheen Item Fits Your Space?
Best for
- Shoppers who want a freestanding place to drop loose change and bills
- Anyone who prefers no wall drilling and likes to move decor around
- A small savings goal that needs easy twist-off access
Not for
- Organizing keys at an entryway or door
- Anyone who wants a wall-mounted item with included hardware
- Holding items larger than what fits through a coin slot
